Skip to Content

Can Dogs Eat Nutter Butters? Safety Tips & Alternatives (2023)

This site is supported by our readers. We may earn a commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase through links.

can dogs eat nutter buttersSnacking on Nutter Butters may be a go-to for humans, but can dogs eat Nutter Butters too? While these sweet treats are not specifically toxic to your pup, there are potential dangers associated with them.

From allergies to obesity and pancreatitis, the risks of feeding your dog Nutter Butters should be taken into consideration.

Fortunately though, there are plenty of alternatives that you can offer instead that will satisfy their cravings without compromising their health. Before serving up any snacks to your four-legged friend – human or otherwise – it’s important to understand what is in them first.

Key Takeaways

  • Nutter butters contain ingredients that can be harmful to dogs, such as wheat, peanuts, soy, xylitol, and theobromine.
  • Consumption of nutter butters can lead to various health risks for dogs, including obesity, pancreatitis, reduced lifespan, vomiting, diarrhea, dental issues, and allergic reactions.
  • It is recommended to monitor for symptoms and contact a veterinarian if a dog eats too many nutter butters. Limiting nutter butters to occasional treats in small amounts or opting for homemade, natural treats without unhealthy additives is a healthier alternative.
  • Checking labels for xylitol, chocolate, and other unhealthy additives, as well as choosing organic treats like Riley’s Peanut Butter Bones, can help ensure the safety of dogs. Moderation is key, and close monitoring of a dog’s consumption is necessary.

Can Nutter Butters Harm Your Dog?

Can Nutter Butters Harm Your Dog
You’re probably aware of the potential risks that come with feeding your furry friend Nutter Butters, but it’s important to always double-check before giving them any treat.

When selecting treats for dogs, consider food allergies and weight management as key factors. Sugar substitutes like xylitol can be toxic ingredients in peanut butter-based snacks such as Nutter Butters, so make sure you check the label before purchasing or serving.

High-fat foods should also be avoided due to the risk of pancreatitis and obesity, which are associated with reduced lifespan and other diseases in dogs.

In addition to these concerns, many store-bought products may have unhealthy additives like artificial flavoring or high fructose corn syrup – both of which could harm their digestive systems over time.

This makes homemade treats using natural ingredients a better alternative where possible.

Potential Dangers of Nutter Butters for Dogs

Potential Dangers of Nutter Butters for Dogs
With Nutter Butters, it’s important to be aware of the potential dangers for your pet. Allergies, obesity, and pancreatitis can all arise from overindulgence in these treats due to their wheat, peanut, and soy ingredients, as well as their high-fat content.


You could be putting your pup at risk of allergies if they eat Nutter Butters, as wheat, soy, and peanuts can all trigger allergic reactions. To avoid this, test for any existing sensitivities prior to feeding them treats.

Monitor their behavior after eating natural peanut butter dog treats with wheat flour in them. Be sure to treat any symptoms immediately when they occur by avoiding the offending food and seeking treatment if needed.


Overeating Nutter Butters can lead to weight gain and obesity in your pup. This is linked to a shorter lifespan and diseases such as diabetes. Too many dietary fats, lack of exercise habits, or unhealthy snack options can all contribute to the problem.

Be aware that toxic xylitol found in some peanut butter products may cause stomach upset if ingested by dogs.


High-fat foods like Nutter Butters can increase your pup’s risk of pancreatitis, which causes serious stomach pain. Avoiding sugar and artificial ingredients is key. Look for organic treats with healthy fats to keep your dog safe from xylitol toxicity in some cookies.

When Are Nutter Butters Safe for Dogs?

When Are Nutter Butters Safe for Dogs
When it comes to feeding your pup Nutter Butters, there are some considerations you should take into account. Dietary concerns, such as calorie counting and the presence of unhealthy ingredients like sugar, artificial flavoring, or high fructose corn syrup, may be a factor in determining if these treats are suitable for your dog.

Treat alternatives, such as Riley’s Organic Peanut Butter Molasses Bone Small, can provide healthy snacks with no wheat, corn, soy, salt, or sugar added. Xylitol risks must also be considered since this ingredient is highly toxic for dogs when ingested in large amounts.

Finally, other safe options exist, including homemade treats utilizing natural ingredients like fish skins and plain chicken breast.

What Happens if My Dog Eats Nutter Butters?

What Happens if My Dog Eats Nutter Butters
If your pup has eaten Nutter Butters, it’s important to monitor them for vomiting, diarrhea, and other signs of illness over the next 24 hours. While these treats are generally safe in moderation for dogs without allergies or weight issues, there is a risk of poisoning from the chocolate coating due to theobromine and xylitol found in some peanut butters.

Obesity can also be an issue with Nutter Butters as they are high in calories and fat, which could lead to pancreatitis if ingested regularly.

Be sure to avoid anything containing wheat flour if your dog is gluten-sensitive too since this can cause digestive problems.

What Can I Offer My Dog Instead of Nutter Butters?

What Can I Offer My Dog Instead of Nutter Butters
You can provide your pup with healthier alternatives to Nutter Butters. Natural treats like homemade snacks let you control the ingredients, while fish skins are packed with healthy fats. Be mindful of health risks from unhealthy ingredients such as sugar, artificial flavoring, and high fructose corn syrup.

Try Riley’s Organic Peanut Butter Molasses Bone Small: certified organic and all-natural with no wheat, corn, or soy; just 6 calories each.

What’s in Nutter Butters?

Nutter Butters contain sugar, artificial flavoring, high fructose corn syrup, and other unhealthy ingredients that can be detrimental to your pup’s digestive system. Avoiding sugar is important for dogs since it can lead to obesity and diabetes, as well as dental problems.

In addition, some peanut butters may contain xylitol, which is highly toxic for dogs. To keep your dog healthy while enjoying treats, opt for ones made with healthy fats like fish skins or plain chicken breast instead of butter-based treats.

Homemade recipes allow you to control the ingredients used, so you can avoid unhealthy fillers or additives in store-bought options.

Natural ingredients such as molasses are a great way of adding flavor without worrying about toxicity risks. Just make sure they don’t exceed the recommended daily allowance guidelines set by veterinarians.

Are There Dog Nutter Butters?

Are There Dog Nutter Butters
Yes, there are dog Nutter Butters around that will have your pooch begging for more! You’ll want to keep an eye out for those unhealthy ingredients like sugar and high fructose corn syrup, as well as wheat flour, which can be problematic for gluten-sensitive dogs.

Instead, look out for organic options like Riley’s Organic Peanut Butter Molasses Bone Small treats. They’re certified organic and all-natural, with no wheat, corn, or soy in them either. They also only contain 6 calories each, so if you do give it to your pup, make sure you monitor their intake accordingly.

The higher caloric content of other Nutter Butters could lead to health risks such as obesity or pancreatitis from consuming too much fat.

All in all, these treats are safe in moderation. Though always remember safety first when it comes to our furry friends’ well-being!

How Do I Know if Peanut Butter is Safe for My Dog?

How Do I Know if Peanut Butter is Safe for My Dog
To ensure your pup’s safety, check the ingredients list of peanut butter products to make sure they don’t contain any unhealthy or toxic additives.

  • Xylitol toxicity – some brands have this sugar substitute, which is highly toxic for dogs.
  • Chocolate coating – this also carries a risk due to its content of theobromine.
  • Risk levels – peanuts and wheat can cause allergies in some breeds, while high-fat foods may increase pancreatitis risks.
  • Homemade treats – these let you control what goes into them and are often healthier options than store-bought snacks.

If you’re unsure about an ingredient in a product, avoid it altogether or opt for organically certified ones with fewer preservatives and artificial flavors that could be harmful to your pet’s digestive system.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Are Nutter Butters Safe for Puppies?

Nutter Butters can be a safe treat for puppies, provided you take the right precautions and avoid unhealthy ingredients. In moderation, with an eye on potential allergies or weight issues, these treats can fit into your pup’s diet like a glove.

Is the Chocolate Coating on Nutter Butters Toxic?

The chocolate coating on Nutter Butters is toxic due to theobromine, posing a potential danger for dogs. It’s best to avoid these treats and consider healthier alternatives such as homemade snacks with natural ingredients or Riley’s Organic peanut butter/molasses treats.

How Much Nutter Butters Should I Give My Dog?

How much Nutter Butter should you give your pup? When in doubt, less is more—it’s always safer to err on the side of caution. Stick with a few pieces as an occasional treat and never exceed the recommended serving size.

What Should I Do if My Dog Eats Too Many Nutter Butters?

If your dog ate too many Nutter Butters, contact your vet immediately. The chocolate coating can be toxic due to theobromine, and wheat, soy, and peanuts may trigger allergic reactions. Too much fat or calories can lead to obesity or pancreatitis, which could reduce lifespan and cause disease.

Consider low-calorie alternatives like homemade treats with natural ingredients for healthier snacks instead of sugar-filled varieties with unhealthy additives.

Are There Any Healthier Alternatives to Nutter Butters for Dogs?

Other healthier alternatives to Nutter Butters for dogs include homemade treats with natural ingredients, fish skins high in healthy fats, plain chicken breast, and Riley’s Organic peanut butter/molasses treats.

Avoid unhealthy ingredients like sugar, artificial flavoring, and high fructose corn syrup.


At the end of the day, the question of whether dogs can eat Nutter Butters is a tricky one. On the one hand, these delicious treats contain ingredients that can potentially be dangerous to your canine friend.

On the other hand, when given in moderation and without any potential allergies or weight issues, they can make a great occasional snack. The important thing is to be very aware of what’s in the treat and to make sure it’s safe for your pup.

If you’re not sure, it’s best to err on the side of caution and offer your pup a healthier alternative.

So, can dogs eat Nutter Butters? With the right precautions and knowledge, the answer is yes!

Avatar for Mutasim Sweileh

Mutasim Sweileh

Mutasim is the founder and editor-in-chief with a team of qualified veterinarians, their goal? Simple. Break the jargon and help you make the right decisions for your furry four-legged friends.