Skip to Content

Top 10 Best Toys for Border Collies for 2024 – Dog Nerdz

This site is supported by our readers. We may earn a commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase through links.

best toys for border colliesDo you have a Border Collie that needs some new toys? With their boundless energy and intelligence, these pups require special attention when it comes to playtime. Luckily, we’ve taken the guesswork out for you with this list of the top 10 best toys for your canine companion in 2023.

From interactive games to chewing options and everything in between – there’s something here just perfect for your pup! Read on as we review each toy, focusing on price, title, brand, and URL. We will also discuss factors like age appropriateness and safety so that you can make an informed decision about what will work best for your pooch.

Key Takeaways

  • The Chuckit Ultra Rubber Ball Dog Toy is durable and suitable for energetic play.
  • The KONG Wubba Classic Dog Toy has reinforced fabric and stitching for increased durability.
  • The Benebone Bacon Dog Chew Toy satisfies the natural urge to chew and promotes relaxation.
  • The Outward Hound Tail Teaser is a chasing and tugging toy that provides exercise and bonding.

Top 10 Best Toys for Border Collies

Finding the right toys for your Border Collie can be challenging. Luckily, there are many excellent options available that offer different types of stimulation and entertainment for your pup. From Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball Dog Toy to Outward Hound Tail Teaser, this list provides an overview of some of the best toys on the market tailored specifically to Border Collies’ needs.

Chuckit Ultra Rubber Ball Dog Toy

Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball ToughView On Chewy
The Chuckit Ultra Rubber Ball Dog Toy is the perfect toy for dogs obsessed with balls. Its extra-thick rubber core makes it bouncier than regular tennis balls, and its bright orange color will ensure it’s always easy to spot.

Compatible with Chuckit! Ball Launchers, this ball is virtually indestructible, making it suitable for super chewers and high-energy dogs alike.

Reviews show that this durable toy stands up to aggressive chewing and allows owners to throw further without straining their arms.

  • Durable rubber material
  • Bouncy design encourages interactive play
  • Bright orange color prevents getting lost easily
  • Compatible with Ball Launchers
  • Virtually indestructible & Floats in Water
  • Not suitable for tough chewers
  • Can be chewed through quickly

JW Pet Chompion Dog Toy

JW Pet Chompion Dog Toy,View On Chewy
Try the JW Pet Chompion Dog Toy for an exceptional teething, fetch, and tug toy that keeps teeth clean and stimulates gums. Made from durable rubber with infused vanilla extract for a delicious flavor, this curious design allows it to be easily tossed or bounced.

Perfect for rolling around, carrying around in your pup’s mouth, or flinging across the room – as well as teething puppies! With its textured nubs to keep teeth clean and stimulate gums throughout playtime, this is a great choice of toy even if you have medium-sized breeds or adult dogs who are not heavy chewers – but always make sure to monitor them when playing with their toys!

Some users reported the toy lasting up to 48 hours with their dog, while others found it didn’t last more than a few hours, particularly due to size variations, so durability may vary. It can also be used alongside treats if desired, which helps keep your pup occupied longer too.

  • Durable rubber construction
  • Infused vanilla extract provides a delicious flavor
  • Textured nubs help promote healthy teeth & gums
  • Not suitable for tough chewers/heavy chewers
  • Size variation affects durability
  • May need additional treats

KONG Wubba Classic Dog Toy

KONG Wubba Classic Dog Toy,View On Chewy
Give your pup a bouncy and squeaky treat with the KONG Wubba Classic Dog Toy. Its reinforced fabric and stitching make it ideal for interactive play or solo fun. This durable, ballistic nylon toy features tails on one end for extra shaking fun.

It also has two tennis balls inside that create the perfect bouncing sound dogs love.

It’s easy to pick up, throw, or tug between you and your pup—perfect for bonding time! And as an added bonus, this affordable toy is available in three random colors, so there’s something to suit everyone’s taste.

  • Durable construction with reinforced fabric and stitching
  • Includes 2 tennis balls inside for maximum bounce and squeakiness
  • Tails at one end make it easy to grab and shake
  • Affordable price point
  • May not last long if chewed aggressively by tough chewers
  • Smaller dogs may easily extract the ball from the center of the toy
  • Some customers have reported that their dog quickly ripped through this product

Benebone Bacon Dog Chew Toy

Benebone Bacon Flavor Wishbone ToughView On Chewy
For a durable chew toy that satisfies your pup’s natural urge to gnaw and promotes relaxation, try the Benebone Bacon Dog Chew Toy. Made in the USA with real bacon and tough nylon, this ergonomic wishbone-shaped toy has deep flavor grooves for easy gripping and comes in various sizes to accommodate different dog breeds.

It helps satisfy your border collie’s natural urges while supporting animal welfare nationwide – a portion of all sales is donated to animal support organizations! Plus, it lasts longer than older versions of Benebone despite regular chewing by strong chewers.

However, some dogs may not be impressed or prefer other toys as its sharp edges could cause tears on furniture when chewed excessively.

  • Durable construction made from tough nylon & real bacon flavoring
  • Ergonomic design with deep flavor grooves for easy gripping
  • Supports animal welfare nationwide; a portion of sales is donated
  • Lasts longer compared to older versions of Benebone
  • Suitable for large puppies & strong chewers
  • Not suitable for small dogs or Jack Russells
  • May have sharp edges & bits falling off after heavy chewing
  • Dogs may not be impressed or prefer other toys
  • Leaves no residue when chewed but material can cause sharp edges

GoDog Dragon Plush Toy

GoDog Dragons Chew Guard SqueakyView On Chewy
The GoDog Dragon Plush Toy is perfect for medium breeds and all breeds, with its double-stitched seams and durable Chew Guard Technology ensuring hours of interactive fun or solo play. It can even withstand tough chewers! The soft texture is gentle on teeth and gums, while the built-in squeaker will keep your pup entertained.

Plus, this toy comes without stuffing, so your pup won’t be able to make a mess if they decide to tear it apart. And there’s no need to worry about durability; the reinforced fabric ensures that this toy will last as long as possible.

It also provides exercise for dogs who love chasing their toys around the house or yard.

  • Double stitched seams for increased durability
  • Soft texture that’s gentler on teeth & gums
  • Can withstand tough chewers & heavy playtime
  • Some customers report issues with durability
  • Not suitable for nibblers or highly destructive chewers

Ethical Pet Dog Chew Toy

Ethical Pet Sensory Ball ToughView On Chewy
You’ll want to consider the Ethical Pet Dog Chew Toy for your pup, a durable and stimulating toy made from TPR with a beef scent and flavor. This toy will appeal to all of your pup’s senses. It has bright colors, multiple textures, beef scent, and flavor.

The tough rubber construction makes it suitable for aggressive chewers, while the small size allows for easy carrying in the dog’s mouth.

  • Made from durable TPR (thermoplastic rubber)
  • Appeals to all of the dog’s senses
  • Contains a bell and squeaker, beef scent and flavor, bright colors, and multiple textures
  • Small enough for comfortable carrying in the dog’s mouth
  • Some customers have concerns about the metal bell inside as a potential choking hazard
  • The strong smell may be unpleasant
  • The squeaker may break easily

ARM Hammer Super Treadz Dog Chew Toy

This ARM & Hammer Super Treadz Dog Chew Toy is the ideal choice for your pup if they’re a tough chewer – so you won’t have to stress about them demolishing it in minutes! Made from extremely durable rubber, this toy helps freshen breath and reduce tartar and plaque buildup.

The fun shapes are designed to keep dogs entertained for hours while baking soda infused into its construction makes dental care easy during playtime. This chew toy stands up well against aggressive chewers as customer reviews show that their pups haven’t been able to destroy it yet.

Plus, many customers agree that even though their dog was initially uninterested due to its strong smell, after some time outside the odor dissipated enough for them to start playing with it again.

  • Durable rubber material can withstand aggressive chewers
  • Freshens breath and reduces tartar/plaque buildup
  • Fun shapes keep dogs entertained for hours
  • Strong chemical smell off-putting at first
  • Can be difficult for treats to dispense from inside
  • Some dogs may tear apart head or fists quickly

Mammoth Tirebiter Dog Toy

Mammoth Tirebiter II Dog ToyView On Chewy
For tough chewers, the Mammoth Tirebiter Dog Toy provides hours of interactive fun and helps build strength with its progressive chew system. Made from natural rubber, this toy is designed for large breeds and encourages rolling, tossing, and tugging.

The durable material will stand up to heavy chew time but may not be suitable for nibblers or highly destructive dogs.

Plus, it’s sustainably manufactured in Mammoth’s North American factory, so you can feel good knowing that it was made ethically.

  • Durable material perfect for aggressive chewing
  • Progressive Chew System builds strength
  • Multiple sizes available
  • Sustainably manufactured
  • Not suitable for nibblers or highly destructive dogs
  • May be smaller than described
  • Some treads may be chewed off over time
  • Not appealing to those uninterested in smell

Nylabone Football Dog Toy

Nylabone Power Play Football GripzView On Chewy
The Nylabone Football Dog Toy is like a playground in your pup’s paws, offering bouncing fun and squeaky excitement. It has an indented shape for easier retrieval and an erratic bounce that adds to the excitement.

Inside is a squeaker to entice play, while its soft texture is gentle on teeth and gums.

It can be thrown up to 100 feet for interactive games of fetch or solo playtime under supervision.

The textile covering has been known to come off easily, making it unusable in some cases.

  • Erratic bounce adds excitement
  • Soft texture gentle on teeth & gums
  • Squeaker inside encourages interaction
  • Not suitable as a throwing toy
  • Textile covering comes off easily
  • May not hold up against tough chewers

Outward Hound Tail Teaser

Outward Hound Tail Teaser withView On Chewy
Experience the thrill of interactive play with Outward Hound Tail Teaser – a toy sure to make your pup go wild! This durable nylon cord comes with a wand and faux-fur tails that squeak and rattle for added fun.

Measuring 88.5 x 1.5 inches, it’s suitable for small breeds as well as larger dogs, encouraging them to chase after the moving target while satisfying their prey drive.

The stick part of this toy may break easily, so it’s not recommended if your dog swallows small fibers. However, many reviews have confirmed its durability against strong pullers, making this an ideal choice when you need something more engaging than other toys in the market today.

  • Suitable for dogs with a prey drive
  • Sturdy enough to withstand strong pulling
  • Engaging toy even if dog isn’t interested in other toys
  • Easy to replace tail part of Toy
  • Good for indoor exercise & tiring out dogs
  • Stick part can be broken off by some dogs
  • Squeaker may stop working over time
  • Not recommended if dog swallows small fibers

Play Style

Play Style
For Border Collies, the best toys should be chosen based on play style. Interactive toys like the Kong Wobbler or ZippyPaws Burrow Hide & Seek Squeaky Plush Toy encourage problem-solving and mental stimulation.

Chew bones like the Benebone Bacon Dog Chew Toy help satisfy your pup’s natural urge to chew and promote relaxation. Chasing and tugging options such as the Outward Hound Tail Teaser provide exercise while bonding with you.

And for chewing, the Mammoth Tirebiter II Dog Toy is a great choice due to its durable rubber construction.

Toys for Interactive Play

Engage your pup in stimulating playtime with interactive toys like the Outward Hound Tail Teaser and KONG Wobbler! Choose from a variety of options, such as chew toys, tug toys, fetch toys, and snuffle mats.

Interactive dog games help keep your Border Collie mentally stimulated while providing hours of fun. Puzzle and treat-dispensing games are great for encouraging problem-solving skills. Hide-and-seek type activities allow them to use their natural hunting instincts to find hidden treats or items around the house – plus, they can be incredibly entertaining for both you and your pup! For those that love chewing on things, there are durable rubber chews that will stand up to even the toughest jaws.

Toys for Chewing

Choose chew toys that are durable and made of rubber, nylon, or rope to keep your pup entertained without compromising safety. The size of the toy should be appropriate for your Border Collie’s chewing habits and dental hygiene needs.

Selecting a safe toy is important as some dogs may attempt to swallow pieces if it becomes too worn down from excessive chewing. Look for toys with bumps or texture that help clean teeth while they play, such as balls with ridges and grooves, wishbone-shaped chews, rubber sticks for fetching games, etc.

Toys designed specifically for Border Collies can provide them mental stimulation and encourage better behavior during their alone time. With so many options available in the market today, make sure you choose one carefully according to their size preference, durability level, and play style.

Toys for Chasing and Tugging

For Border Collies who love chasing and tugging, try the Outward Hound Tail Teaser for interactive playtime that’s fun for both you and your pup!

Perfect for strong jaws and high energy levels, it features a durable nylon cord with a squeaky faux fur tail.

Other great toys include:

  • KONG Classic Dog Toy – perfect for fetch
  • Jolly Pets Romp n’ Roll Ball & Rope Combo – encourages chewing
  • Nylabone Football Gripz Dog Toy – ideal size to carry in mouth with erratic bounce
  • Chuckit! Ultra Duo Tug Tough Dog Toy – rubber balls on each end make this toy tough yet playable.

Choose various toys based on your dog’s preferences—tugging technique, strategies, games—to keep them entertained while promoting safety.


When it comes to durability, strong rubber and nylon toys are the best for Border Collies. Toys made with tough materials and reinforced stitching can withstand aggressive chewing, while those designed specifically for heavy chewers will last even longer.

Toys Made of Tough Rubber or Nylon

Treat yourself and your pup to tough rubber or nylon toys for energetic, interactive play. Ideal for active breeds like Border Collies, these durable materials will withstand hours of chewing and tugging.

Check dog toy safety tips before buying; make sure any chew toys don’t have detachable parts that could be a choking hazard or non-toxic materials used in their construction.

Textured toys made from tough rubber or nylon can provide dental stimulation as well as an engaging game of fetch! Consider age appropriateness when purchasing — for puppies, look into softer options such as plush textiles while older dogs may need something tougher to keep them interested during playtime.

Toys With Reinforced Stitching

Reinforced stitching adds extra durability to toys, allowing them to withstand heavy use from your pup. Chew-proofing with strong stitching is especially important for working breeds like Border Collies and their prey drive.

Rubber designs are great for chew-resistant options, as rubber materials can naturally stand up better against chewing than other materials.

Nylon provides more flexibility but also increased strength in its design so that it stands up well against chewing and rough playtime activity.

With all types of toys available today ranging from plush st■ animals to puzzle games, reinforced stitches ensure maximum durability no matter what type you choose for your beloved pooch!

Toys Designed for Aggressive Chewers

If your pup is an aggressive chewer, look for toys made with durable rubber like the ARM & Hammer Super Treadz Dog Chew Toy that will help freshen breath and reduce tartar buildup. For chew-proofing, consider toy sizing appropriate to breed-specific needs and make sure there are no detachable parts or materials that could be toxic.

Puzzle games, such as the Nina Ottosson Twister Dog Toy Game, or a snuffle mat can provide mental stimulation. Cheaper toys, like tennis balls, allow physical activity without breaking the bank.

Always prioritize safety when choosing any type of toy for your dog and avoid those with squeakers that can easily be removed by curious pups!

Age Appropriateness

Age Appropriateness
When choosing toys for your Border Collie, it’s important to consider the age appropriateness of the toy.

For puppies, interactive and puzzle toys are ideal as they help develop physical and mental skills. Toys such as Ourpets IQ Treat Ball or Playay Dental treat ball can keep young pups entertained while also providing treats for reward-based learning.

For adult dogs, durable rubber chew toys like Kong Classic Dog Toy or Chuckit Ultra Rubber Ball Dog Toy are best for fetching and chewing sessions.

Lastly, senior dogs should be provided with softer plush dog toys that will not damage their gums or teeth when chewed on. Nylabone Football Gripz Dog Toy is a great choice due to its soft texture and beef scent, which provides stimulation even in older years.

Toys Suitable for Puppies

For puppies, plush toys and hide-and-seek games are great choices to keep your pup engaged. Border Collie pups have a playful nature and are highly food motivated, making them ideal candidates for interactive toys that dispense treats.

Puzzle toys with different levels of difficulty can challenge their intelligence, while fetch and chew toys provide physical activity.

Treats should be used sparingly as they may become reliant on them: try using other rewards like praise or chews instead! Toys such as Kong Wobbler, ZippyPaws Woodland Friends Burrow, Trixie Chess Activity Game, or Outward Hound Tail Teaser will ensure hours of enjoyment.

Toys Suitable for Adult Dogs

Choose toys with reinforced fabric and stitching for adult dogs, such as the Chuckit Ultra Rubber Ball Dog Toy, JW Pet Chompion Dog Toy, or KONG Wubba Classic Dog Toy. These toys provide hours of interactive play. Puzzle toys like Trixie Chess Activity Game or Nina Ottosson’s Twister require problem-solving skills to gain treats.

Treat dispensing games like Ourpets IQ Treat Ball challenge canines mentally while providing a tasty reward.

Hide-and-seek dog toy options include ZippyPaws Woodland Friends Burrow, and Outward Hound Tail Teaser is great for chasing fun too! Fetch games are popular with older Border Collies.

Toys Suitable for Senior Dogs

When it comes to senior dogs, consider toys that are gentle on their sensitive teeth and gums. The Ethical Pet Sensory Ball Tough Dog Chew Toy is chew-resistant and has bumps and ridges for extra stimulation.

For squeaky plush play, the ZippyPaws Donutz provides hours of fun with its soft texture. Puzzle games like the Trixie Chess Activity Game offer mentally stimulating play with treats as a reward, while the Outward Hound Tail Teaser encourages interactive chasing or tugging sessions.


When choosing toys for your Border Collie, it is important to prioritize safety. Avoid toys with detachable parts that could become choking hazards and avoid those made of toxic materials. Additionally, make sure to choose toys that are the appropriate size for your dog; too small or large can be dangerous as well.

Avoid Toys With Detachable Parts

To keep your pup safe, avoid toys with detachable parts that could cause choking hazards. Select toys based on the size and chewing habits of your Border Collie. Avoid toy parts made from toxic materials or small pieces that can be swallowed by an active dog.

Choose durable materials like rubber, nylon rope, or plush fabric for long-lasting enjoyment and safety. Busy families should opt for clever breeds trained using toys in shapes and sizes suitable to prevent ingestion danger during playtime sessions.

For a healthy chew routine, choose large bones with beef flavor as these will last longer than traditional options without causing any harm to your beloved pup! Remember – when it comes to selecting the right toy for them, always prioritize safety over cost so you can enjoy many happy years together as part of a loving family unit!

Avoid Toys Made of Toxic Materials

Always check the material of toys for your pup, as some may contain dangerous toxins that could harm them.

Make sure to avoid:

  • Toys with small parts which can be a choking hazard for puppies or allergic dogs.
  • Toxic materials such as plastic and rubber that are not safe for pet consumption.
  • Paints and dyes on toy surfaces which can cause skin irritation or other health problems if ingested by an intelligent yet active dog like a Border Collie puppy during playtime.

When selecting the right toy, buyers should take into account size, type of material used, cost, and age appropriateness in order to provide hours of safe fun while avoiding any potential hazards from toxic substances in their selection process.

Choose Toys That Are the Appropriate Size for Your Dog

Choose toys that fit your pup’s size – whether small or large – for the best experience. When selecting a toy, consider what type of playing options your Border Collie needs. Chew toys, fetch toys, hide and seek games, and snuffle mats all provide different mental stimulation.

Pick the best toy based on their age. Puppies may need softer plush options, while an older dog might prefer puzzle-based activities. For energetic dogs like border collies, interactive or treat-dispensing toys can be great for keeping them entertained.

Choose durable materials such as rubber or nylon to get the most out of each purchase and find something with bright colors so you don’t lose it in tall grass! Avoid toxic chemicals when possible to keep your dog safe from harm during playtime at home or outdoors.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What kind of toys are best for border collies?

For Border Collies, a variety of interactive and puzzle toys are best. For example, the Outward Hound Tail Teaser is great for chasing and tugging games, while Nina Ottosson’s Twister Dog Toy Game offers an advanced challenge with treats as rewards.

How can I keep my border collie entertained?

Treat your Border Collie to a world of stimulation and exploration! By choosing interactive toys, puzzle games, treat dispensers, hide-and-seek toys, and more, you can create an exciting playground for them.

Offer variety in their playtime experiences – like the branches of a tree swaying with the wind – so they never get bored.

Does my border collie need to be supervised when playing with toys?

It’s always best to supervise your Border Collie when playing with toys, especially if they’re known for chewing. Toys should be engaging and stimulating, like a symphony of colors in the sky. Inspect them regularly to ensure there are no pieces that can break off or become choking hazards – safety first! Keep an eye out for signs of boredom or destructive behaviors so you can switch up their playtime activities.

How often should I replace my border collie’s toys?

To ensure your border collie’s toys are safe and stimulating, replace them every three months or so. On average, dogs use a toy for about two to four weeks before tiring of it – but this varies depending on usage and quality.

Are puzzle toys suitable for border collies?

Yes, puzzle toys are a great way to provide mental stimulation for Border Collies. They can help keep them entertained while rewarding them with treats when they complete the task.


Wow! There are some amazing toys out there for Border Collies that can keep them active, mentally stimulated, and entertained. From interactive puzzles, treat dispensers, and hide-and-seek toys to chew toys, tug toys, and fetch toys, there’s something for every Border Collie.

When choosing the best toys for your pup, consider the size, play style, durability, cost, and age appropriateness. Remember to prioritize safety and avoid toys with detachable parts or toxic materials.

Avatar for Mutasim Sweileh

Mutasim Sweileh

Mutasim is the founder and editor-in-chief with a team of qualified veterinarians, their goal? Simple. Break the jargon and help you make the right decisions for your furry four-legged friends.