10 Best Dry Dog Foods for Liver Diseases 2021

13 min

Thank you for actively trying to improve your best friend’s quality of life by searching for the best dry dog food for liver disease.

best dry dog food for liver diseaseDogs with liver issues require special attention to their diet, and in this review, you will find some great choices for the best food to feed a dog with liver problems.

Dog food for liver health is an important treatment tool for dogs with impaired liver function.

The liver is intended to cleanse the body by removing toxins and waste products and helps with indigestion.

If the liver is not functioning properly, the toxins and waste can accumulate, causing dysfunction of other body systems.

If your dog already has liver disease, there are dog foods for liver disease on the market that can make it easier for them.

Your dog may need a dietary change to help the liver regenerate. This also helps to maintain good dog food.

You need to know what ingredients your dog’s food contains and whether those ingredients are healthy for a dog with liver disease.

The wrong ingredients can build up toxins in the liver – for example, a high sodium diet can make your dog’s liver disease worse.

So buying the purest and best dog food for liver diseasewith the least amount of preservatives, fillers, and sodium will help your dog’s digestion, which will reduce liver stress.

To help you understand this common problem and cause liver disease, we are here to give you all the important information about it.

We also give you a list of the best dry dog foods for liver disease.

Top 5 Best Dry Dog Foods for Liver Disease (Quick Summary)

Nutro MAX Adult Dry Dog Nutro Wholesome Essentials Max Adult Dry
  • Affordable
  • All-natural, no preservatives or artificial flavors
  • Amazon's choice
Hill's Prescription Diet l/d Liver Hill’s Prescription Diet L/d Liver Care Original Canned Dog Food
  • Specially formulated for liver disease
  • Regenerates tissues and cells
  • Helps flush out toxins
Purina Pro Plan With Probiotics Purina Pro Plan Savor Shredded Blend With Probiotics
  • Proven brand
  • Live probiotics
  • Contains omega-6 fatty acids and linoleic acid
ROYAL CANIN Canine Hepatic Dry Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Hepatic Formula Dry Dog Food
  • Low copper levels reduce copper levels in the liver
  • Digestible plant proteins boost liver health
  • Antioxidants support a healthy immune system
The Honest Kitchen Human Grade The Honest Kitchen Whole Grain Turkey Dog Food
  • Easy to absorb and digest
  • Free-range and game food
  • Essential vitamins and nutrients
Prices/Images/Reviews pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on: 23/09/2021 21:20 PM

What Causes of Liver Disease in Dogs?

What Causes Liver Disease In Dogs?

There is not one thing that causes liver disease. There are many things that you cannot control, such as aging and genetics. Older dogs are usually more susceptible to liver disease, and specific dog breeds are also at risk.

Dobermans, Rottweilers, Yorkshire Terriers, and Cocker Spaniels are genetically susceptible to liver problems, and Doberman Pinschers (especially females) can sometimes inherit chronic hepatitis.

Other breeds with difficulty excreting copper (which can lead to copper-associated hepatitis) are Bedlingtons and West Highland White Terriers.

Liver disease can also be caused by infections, exposure to toxins, or too many medicines.

In short, if a dog takes a too high dose of a certain drug or takes a specific drug too long, this can lead to liver disease.

Cancer can also be a cause of the disease.

Symptoms to Watch Out for May Indicate Dog’s Liver Disease

The symptoms of liver disease in the dog can be similar to almost any other condition your dog suffers from:

  • Weakness
  • Depression
  • Fatigue
  • Loss of appetite
  • Weight loss
  • Vomiting
  • Abdominal pain

The way to know for sure if liver disease is the culprit is to take your dog to the vet for a checkup and diagnosis. The good news is, the sooner you discover the truth, the sooner you can get your dog on good dog food for liver disease, and that means the better his quality of life will be.

10 Best Dry Dog Foods For Liver Diseases

When it comes to healthy dog food, you can give many suggestions from your vet. It is important to check and read the labels to know exactly which supplements the food provides for liver disease.

This way, you can also choose foods that are high in vitamins and low in copper.

Here is the list of best dog foods for liver disease:

1. Nutro Wholesome Essentials Max Adult Dry

Nutro Wholesome Essentials Max Adult DryView On Amazon

Nutro dog food soon becomes one of the most popular natural dog food brands. Founded as a family business in California in 1926, the company also has a long history in the best dog foods industry.

Nutro Wholesome Essentials Max Adult Dry 1The Nutro Max line was created in 1985 by Dr.Sharon Machlik, and even as a more expensive premium line, sales increased. The company has also built a reputation as a proponent of natural dog food by informing dog owners about nutrition’s importance.

Nutro emphasizes the use of only natural ingredients in their dog food. They do this by relying on local farmers to produce all their components.

Their formula is good for dogs with liver problems but has been developed to provide dogs with a fully balanced diet. It not only helps your dog’s liver, but the rich mix also helps your digestion, immune system, and dental health.

The vitamins and minerals are of natural origin and rich in proteins, promoting muscle mass and a shiny coat.

The formula of Nutro Max also varies by the size of the dog and the stage in life. It also comes in both dry and wet versions, depending on your preference. There is also a wide range of blends and combinations, so you will certainly find your dog’s favorite type of meat in their range.

The characteristic ingredient of Nutro that has been consistent for years is their chicken farm. Healthy chickens are equal to healthy dogs and people who eat them!

This dog food is full of essential vitamins and minerals to meet your dog’s full nutritional needs and help with liver disorders.

Their low protein dog food for liver disease is high quality, lean, and enriched with amino acids that help your dogs grow and develop from puppy to adult.

  • Affordable
  • All-natural, no preservatives or artificial flavors
  • Amazon’s choice
  • Brand reputation
  • Availability outside of North America

Customer Reviews
1,189 Reviews

Avatar Amazon_Shark


Best dog food

Let me start by saying I’ve been using Nutro dry and wet dog food for over 15 years and my dogs LOVE it. Nutro in general is high quality, no by-products, also great for dogs with sensitive stomachs.This particular variety is for my English Bulldog, he is not overweight and doesn’t look malnourished either. He is active and enjoys eating it. Food pellets are about the size of a penny and have a chicken smell. They do not smell bad. No oily residue and easy clean up.

2. Hill’s Prescription Diet l/d Liver Care Original Canned Dog Food

Hill’s Prescription Diet l/d Liver Care Original Canned Dog FoodView On Amazon

The liver is one of the most important body parts of your dog. It comes with many functions. This is good canned dog food for liver disease. It can help support liver health. It is made from vitamins E and C, digestible protein, and reduced sodium. That is why you can feed your pet this recipe. There are no worries about added supplements.

This product has been designed to reduce VAT. Your dog’s liver tissue can, therefore, regenerate. It also helps to maintain normal fat metabolism in his liver.

The recipe helps remove toxins from the blood and builds up in the system to make digestion natural and effortless. It is designed to regrow vital tissues, prevent nutritional deficiencies, and promote healthy immunity.

35% Off at Chewy.com

35% Off at Chewy.com

+ Free Shipping

Claim The Offer

Moreover, with this best dry dog food for liver disease, you do not have to worry about nutrient deficiencies that can often lead to liver problems. Finally, it can support your dog’s immune system.

  • Specially formulated for liver disease
  • Regenerates tissues and cells
  • Helps flush out toxins
  • Reduces nutritional deficiencies
  • S OXSHIELD for urinary health
  • Some dogs may not like the taste.

Customer Reviews
167 Reviews

Avatar Ms. Johnson

Ms. Johnson

Availability of the prescribed dog food

I thought by changing my dogs diet he would be picky. Nope he loves the food the vet prescribed for him.

3. Purina Pro Plan SAVOR Shredded Blend With Probiotics

Purina Pro Plan SAVOR Shredded Blend With ProbioticsView On Amazon

Purina is a brand that has been active since 2001 and supplies a wide range of top quality food for cats and dogs.

Purina Pro Plan SAVOR Shredded Blend With Probiotics 1The Purina Pro Plan test line with probiotics is an excellent choice for the dog’s overall health, especially digestion. In this specific mix, they have given it a boost by recording live probiotics.

A healthy digestive system means less stress on the liver, making Purina an excellent dog food choice for liver problems.

The best dog food for liver disease is that it uses lamb and rice as primary ingredients. It offers balanced nutrition with optimum levels of protein, fiber, and fat. Also included are crucial vitamins, nutrients, and omega acids for a balanced diet.

The Purina Pro Plan Savor mix contains vitamin A, linoleic acid, and omega-6 to keep your dog healthy.
Purina’s blend also has prebiotic fibers that naturally come from wheat bran. This gives an extra (fiber punch) to make digestion even easier for your puppy.

The combination of fiber, probiotics, and lamb/rice makes this a great mix for daily use that reduces the liver’s burden. Will relieve your dog, thereby improving overall health.

  • Proven brand
  • Live probiotics
  • Contains omega-6 fatty acids and linoleic acid
  • Expensive

Customer Reviews
9,965 Reviews

Avatar Ashley Bouchard

Ashley Bouchard

She says it gives them great nutrition and is affordable

I switched to this dog food from Blue Buffalo, my sister in law is a vet tech and this is what she feeds her dogs. She says it gives them great nutrition and is affordable. My dog especially loves the shredded bits. If you found this review helpful, please click yes 🙂

4. Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Hepatic Formula Dry Dog Food

Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Hepatic Formula Dry Dog FoodView On Amazon

Royal Canin hepatic dog food Formula is the best vet recommended dog food formulated to boost your dog’s liver function.

Key Ingredients:

  • Brewer’s Rice
  • Brown Rice
  • soy protein Isolate
  • Corn
  • Chicken Fat

These foods are low in copper and contain good amounts of zinc, which is great because they help lower the liver’s copper levels.

The royal canin hepatic dog food contains little copper and sodium. It is added with boosted zinc and vitamin B.

This is a good choice for your dog’s digestion due to its fiber content. The food actually does vegetable protein for your dog.

We also have the Royal Canin Canine Hepatic Can with the same benefits as this version. However, it is designed in a softer texture.

  • Low copper levels reduce copper levels in the liver
  • Digestible plant proteins boost liver health
  • Antioxidants support a healthy immune system
  • A tasty diet is great for picky eaters
  • Chunks may be too big for small puppies

Customer Reviews
89 Reviews

Avatar kristy


Perfect labs Thanks to a new diet

My 1 year old French bulldog had liver problems...high liver enzymes and high bile acids. We put him on meds Denamarin and lactulose. Twice a month for 3 months we took him in to the vet to test his liver and bile acids and the results were high. We also took him to a specialist for a liver ultrasound. No shunts were found but his results were still high. I took him off Royal Canin puppy and replaced it with the Royal Canin hepatic. I also fed him home cooked organic low protein high veggies and fruit diet. Needless to ...

5. The Honest Kitchen Whole Grain Turkey Dog Food

The Honest Kitchen Whole Grain Turkey Dog FoodView On Amazon

The dog food from The Honest Kitchen is made from simple and natural ingredients.

The Honest Kitchen Whole Grain Turkey Dog Food 1The recipe is actually composed of free-range protein, vitamin E, zinc, and sodium. This is essential for your dog’s liver because sodium is one of the major causes of dogs’ liver problems.

The grain-free formula of The Honest Kitchen is also available in cage-free turkey and wild-caught fish. Therefore, it ensures that your pet gets natural, GMO-free ingredients to keep your dog’s liver free of toxins.

By giving your dog the purest food source, you ensure easier digestion and less liver stress.

The honest kitchen dog food is a great option for puppies and adult dogs of all shapes and sizes. It is also free of preservatives and by-products, with ingredients made 100% in the United States. They offer some great sources of wild and natural proteins, such as fish caught in the wild.

The materials are 100% standard for people, and they declare that their suppliers meet the standards for fair trade.

The 10-pound formula makes 40 pounds of food, so it is practical to order online. In fact, it is diced so that nutrients can be absorbed more easily and offer perfect nutrition.

The Honest Kitchen is quickly becoming a popular choice for dog owners in the US.

  • Easy to absorb and digest
  • Free-range and game food
  • Essential vitamins and nutrients
  • Price

Customer Reviews
5,274 Reviews

Avatar m. badgley

m. badgley

No other food company compares...review from veterinary personnel

In working in the veterinary field I've seen how important it is that pets get adequate nutrition to prevent or treat various medical issues. I've seen the negative outcomes of poorer pet food quality. I have a mini schnauzer that before had digestive issues, straining when trying to defecate, bloating, really hard dark stools, licking at the feet. He just wasn't himself and I could see and sense that he was very uncomfortable. I switched him to THK turkey and took him off of dry kibble completely. One thing I like to tell people is that I work for a ...

6. Wilderness Blue Buffalo Adult Dry Dog Food

Wilderness Blue Buffalo Adult Dry Dog FoodView On Amazon

This dog food is one of the best options for liver disease. It is formulated with many natural ingredients, made from real meat protein. It is free of grains. Instead, it contains many vitamins and minerals. The food is also added with antioxidants.

Wilderness Blue Buffalo Adult Dry Dog Food 1It ensures that all the essential proteins your dog needs are provided, from chicken flour, boneless chicken, and turkey flour.

It also offers healthy complex carbohydrates from peas, sweet potatoes, and potatoes.

Also, the food is available in antioxidants from cranberries, blueberries, and carrots.

Blue Buffalo is a relatively young company that produces healthy pet food with natural and wild ingredients. The company has four product lines for dogs Wilderness, Life Protection, Freedom, and Basics.

They include a wide range of dog food, including canned food, chunks, and treats for dogs and cats.

Their Wilderness formula is grain-free chicken or wild salmon to ensure that your dog receives the highest quality protein. It also contains healthy carbohydrates such as sweet potatoes and peas.

The Wilderness formula also contains all the necessary vitamins, including both omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids.

What is unique about the Wilderness formula is the patented LifeSource Bits, a mixture of antioxidants, minerals, and vitamins. Holistic veterinarians prepare to ensure that your pet gets a perfectly balanced diet.

You can be sure that your dog meets all his needs through Wilderness, which quickly becomes a popular choice if you are looking for an alternative brand that is quickly becoming more popular.

  • Grain free
  • Completely natural
  • The protein content may be too high
  • Vet approval required

Customer Reviews
10,935 Reviews

Avatar john McILroy

john McILroy

great food for diabetic dog

our Bearded collie developed diabetes. this food works well because it has no grain (carbohydrates ) to spike blood sugar

7. Forza10 Sensitive Digestion Grain-Free Dry Dog Food

Forza10 Sensitive Digestion Grain-Free Dry Dog FoodView On Amazon

Forza 10 is a newer company compared to other brands that have been around for more than 40 years.

Founded in 1996 by Dr. Ir. ir. Ir. Sergio Canello, an Italian veterinarian who specializes in homeopathy, natural medicine, and food-related problems.

The head office is located in Italy, and the company uses 100% domestic naturally raised pork as an ingredient.

They also export worldwide and become a popular choice for dog owners.

The Sensitive Digestion line is made to tackle dogs with digestive problems, including liver problems. Using their philosophy (health through nutrition) is also the perfect dog food for preventive health and offers a complete nutritional balance.

This formula also does not contain grains to promote digestion, which is also an important feature of their products. This special mix is made from wild anchovies to get enough protein and omega-3 and omega-6 oils.

The mix is made from raw natural materials that your dog will love!

Even better, Forza10 uses some unique natural ingredients in their blends. You can expect to find oregano, sage, turmeric, dried rose hips, and psyllium seed husks in their formula, to name just a few.

Many of these natural ingredients offer unique health benefits, making Forza10 an excellent choice for a more holistic approach.

  • Raw, natural and grain-free dog food
  • Unique formula with a homeopathic approach
  • Includes omega-3 and omega-6 oils
  • A bit expensive

Customer Reviews
5 Reviews

Avatar karenbetz


Better than prescription diets

This has been the greatest food ever! My dogs no longer have digestive issues.

8. Nature’s Variety Instinct Grain-Free Dry

Nature’s Variety Instinct Grain-Free DryView On Amazon

If you are looking for a rich product in vitamins and minerals, you can opt for this dog food. This food promises to give your little furry friend a great taste because it is made from grain-free, high-protein, and freeze-dried raw coated chunks.

Nature’s Variety Instinct Grain-Free Dry 1Feed your pet this recipe. And he can get a natural nutrient-rich diet. You can feed the food for even smaller mouths by adding the perfect lumps.

This option is balanced levels of proteins, calories, and fats. That makes it great for the dog’s lifestyle.

It is added with healthy omega 3 fatty acids. Your pet can, therefore, get a soft and shiny coat. You can also find added vitamins and minerals in this recipe.

There is no grain, gluten, wheat, corn, soy, fillers, flavors, artificial colors, or preservatives.

These ingredients can help to cleanse the liver. On the contrary, food is low in copper and sodium.

  • Raw coated food
  • Grain free and completely natural
  • Not for larger breed puppies
  • Possible digestive sensitivity
  • Recent recipe change

Customer Reviews
1,745 Reviews

Avatar Diana C.

Diana C.

Las mejores croquetas

Es un producto muy bueno, que mantiene el pelaje de mi Yorkie súper brillante, el tamaño de la croqueta es perfecto, y con buen olor para llamar la atención del perro; llegó en buenas condiciones! No tuve problema ni con el producto ni con el embalaje

9. Halo Vegan Dry Dog Food

Halo Vegan Dry Dog FoodView On AmazonIt is the best dog food for liver disease for the money. As the name implies, it is completely plant-based and contains no animal by-products. It comes in a few different bag sizes so you can buy as much as you need.

Because people with liver disease can be sensitive to animal protein, this food offers a great alternative. Halo provides the same percentage of protein needed and is fully digestible. It’s all-natural, non-GMO, and grain-free. are no preservatives or added artificial flavors.

This dog food is much cheaper by comparison and delivers the same fantastic nutrition, especially for vegan recipes. It may need to be supplemented with other additives recommended by your vet. However, it is the best value on the list due to its high quality and affordability.

  • Affordable
  • Non-GMO
  • Vegetable protein
  • Cheaper than other vegan options
  • Vegan food may not be suitable for all special diets

Customer Reviews
1,461 Reviews

Avatar RKB


Love Halo Vegan!

*** WHILE THIS BRAND WORKS FOR US, I AM NOT A VET SO TAKE MY VIEW AS A MEDICAL ADVICE. *** My Mini Schnauzer has a congenital liver shunt. This means that she cannot have a high protein content in her diet. For years we bought prescription dog food. Besides being quite expensive, it also used fat as the main source of kcal, which is something I don't feel comfortable with either. So I decided to look for alternatives. I noticed that vegan formulas are also low in animal protein. We tried several brands, but she only really liked Halo. ...

10. Wellness Complete Health

Wellness Complete HealthView On AmazonThe Wellness Complete Health contains only natural ingredients and super nutrients that promote adult dogs’ full health. The formula is made from delicious boneless chicken, oatmeal, and peas, which provide a feeling of fullness and promote healthy body weight.

The Wellness Complete Health Natural is free from unnecessary fillers (such as corn, wheat, and soy), non-nutritious meat by-products, and harmful additives (such as colors, preservatives, and flavorings). The formula is also enriched with added vitamins, especially vitamins E, which are crucial for the liver’s proper functioning and minerals that promote a healthy and strong immune system.

Wellness Complete Health is proudly designed and manufactured in the USA.

Key Features
  • Promote Complete Health
  • Free Fillers, Meat By-Products & Additives
  • Weight Management Recipe
  • Made in the USA.

Customer Reviews
5,049 Reviews

Avatar sue one

sue one

Veterinarian highly recommended

Wellness pet food is in my opinion the best quality pet food out there, and I am a long time holistic veterinarian who used it for my own pet and in the past for other pets. Wellness foods do not contain wheat, corn, soy, additivesand preservatives.They are an ideal holistic food for healthy pets and for pets that require a restricted diet due to food sensitivities of any kind and never contain potentially problematic ingredients.This is the case with my beloved rescue dog who as a puppyhad to have a specific restricted healthy diet that if she ate anything else, ...

Recommended Dog Supplements for Liver Disease

Some of the best dog supplements for liver disease are:

  • Vitamin B
  • Vitamin E
  • Zinc
  • Vitamin C
  • Vitamin K
  • Adenosylmethionine (SAMe)

If you are looking for a specific low copper dog food brands, look for rich vitamins. They are easy to find in many of the high-quality dog food brands.

It can be difficult to find a dog food brand without copper but find one that has it in tiny quantities, which means it is found at the end of the ingredient list. Copper amino acid complex (or chelate) is also a holistic ingredient that is structured differently, so it’s not that harmful.

What Can We Do to Treat Dog Liver Disease?

sad looking cocker spaniel puppy dog sitting - depression dog s and pictures What Can We Do To Treat Dog Liver Disease?

If liver disease is treated before cirrhosis (enters the cirrhosis phase), sufficient liver tissue can be regenerated for the liver to function normally. If not, the disease is terminal.

However, the treatment of liver disease is complex and variable. Your veterinarian, not this article, must set your specific treatment method.

You have read how many different causes of the liver disease there are, so it makes sense to assume that the treatments vary so much, if not more.

Your veterinarian can prescribe medication and vitamins for your puppy, and they can also make some suggestions about their diet.

Dogs with liver disease need the best food for dogs with liver disease that differs from your standard menu setting. But the interesting thing here is that you have some control in the fight against your dog’s liver disease, so let’s examine it!

Let Your Dog Eat

Sometimes dogs with liver disease seem to lose their appetite. This may be due to the disease’s discomfort and because the food with fewer proteins may be less tasty for them.

If you need help getting a dog with a liver disease to eat, trying to make one of the home-made diets makes a difference because it can be more tempting than dry chunks. If your vet agrees, you can try mixing some of the prescribed wet food diets with the kibble.

You can also talk to your veterinarian about adding some fresh items to your dog’s food to increase their interest, such as a low-sodium vegetable broth or fresh vegetables and fish.

How to Prevention of Liver Disease in Dogs?

love and kindness to animals concept - depression dog s and pictures How To Prevent Dog Liver Disease?

As I said above, things like genetics or aging cannot, of course, be prevented. There is no youthful fountain for us, and unfortunately, the same applies to our loyal cohorts.

Part of aging means that dogs (and you, relatively) will experience a decrease in overall system function.

Also, as mentioned above, infectious diseases can be a source of liver disease. That is why it is important to take your dog to the vet if he is sick and receives prompt and effective care for his illness.

Also, visit your local vet regularly and have yourself checked (not you, the dog). Some routine blood tests can measure your dog’s liver health.

There are some natural toxins in plants, and there are naturally harmful chemicals stored directly in your home.

Restrict Max’s access to these dangerous areas and make sure that he does not play too hard, or at least not so hard, that he damages his internal organs (that would be quite an intense playing time).

But before you go, relax around bubbles, wrap sharp corners, put things in the attic, or throw away the dubious houseplant that you’ve received as a gift. As long as you keep a close eye on your dog and know what to look out for, it’s fine.

The easiest thing you can do to keep your dog’s liver healthy is to offer a healthy lifestyle.

Feed them well (but not too much!) And make sure they move enough. Remember that the best defense is good preparation.

FAQs About Dog Food for Liver Disease

How Can My Dog ​​get Liver Disease?

The most common viral disease associated with the liver in dogs is infectious hepatitis in dogs. Leptospirosis is a bacterial infection that dogs can contract from coming into contact with urine contaminated soil or water, leading to liver disease.

How Can I Improve My Dog’s Liver Function?

A vet will need to see how much damage there is to the liver. Diet changes often help. Your dog may need a special diet to ensure he is getting the nutrients and calories he needs to help his liver. Milk thistle can help restore the liver.

Can a Dog’s Liver Repair Itself?

It is not reversible. Before the liver reaches this terminal stage, it can recover from damage and heal itself to the point where your dog has a normal liver function. This is possible if the right treatment is instituted early, and the degree of recovery depends on the exact cause of the liver damage.

Can the Liver Disease Be Painful for My Dog?

It depends on the cause and symptoms causing the liver disease. These can range from very specific to very vague. Most dogs experience a feeling of malaise that progresses to vomiting, nausea, weight loss, anorexia, diarrhea, and possibly abdominal pain. In some cases, liver disease can be painful for your dog.


As promised earlier, the goal of this article is to help you successfully navigate the plethora of food choices for dogs with liver problems.

Liver disease is nothing to brush away. Your dog needs you to get it here. To help through. We hope this list has allayed some anxiety so you can help him on the road to recovery.

Like it? Share with your friends!

600 shares, 2048 points
Mutasim Sweileh
Mutasim is a published author and software engineer and beard care expert from the US. To date, he has helped thousands of men make their beards look better and get fatter. His work has been mentioned in countless notable publications on men's care and style and has been cited in Seeker, Wikihow, GQ, TED, and Buzzfeed.


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *