Skip to Content

Best Dog Food for Picky Eaters: Top 10 Tasty Options to Tempt Any Pooch (2024)

This site is supported by our readers. We may earn a commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase through links.

best dog food for picky eatersAre you struggling to find the best dog food for your picky eater? Don’t worry, you’re not alone.

Pups with discerning tastes often turn up their noses at standard kibble. Try enticing aromas like savory meats or umami flavors. American Journey’s salmon recipe, Nom Nom’s probiotic blend, or Open Farm’s freeze-dried raw options are worth a sniff.

Mixing wet and dry varieties, along with healthy toppers like bone broth or Greek yogurt, can also tempt finicky appetites.

Ready to discover more mouthwatering solutions?

Key Takeaways

  • Unleashing the power of irresistible scents and flavors like savory meats or mouthwatering umami can awaken even the pickiest pup’s appetite.
  • Mixing it up with a variety of textures, from crunchy kibble to luscious pâtés, can be the key to keeping your furbaby’s taste buds on their toes.
  • Don’t underestimate the allure of a little something extra on the side – drizzling a bit of bone broth or sprinkling some Greek yogurt can transform a ho-hum meal into a gourmet feast for your furry foodie.
  • When all else fails, it might be time to roll up your sleeves and get cooking – whipping up a homemade feast with human-grade ingredients could be the ultimate temptation for your discerning diner.

Top 10 Best Dog Foods for Picky Eaters

For picky eaters, you’ll want to explore enticing dog food options that tempt their senses and cater to their preferences. The top 10 best dog foods for picky eaters range from salmon-based recipes to human-grade wet and freeze-dried raw options, offering a variety of flavors, textures, and high-quality ingredients to satisfy even the most discerning pooches.

1. American Journey Salmon Dog Food

American Journey Protein & GrainsView On Chewy
You’re looking for a highly nutritious yet irresistible dog food to tempt your picky pooch.

American Journey Salmon Dog Food delivers with real, deboned salmon as the first ingredient, providing a savory taste dogs love.

Its precise blend of antioxidants, veggies like sweet potatoes, and fiber-rich grains supports overall wellbeing.

DHA aids brain and vision development.

Plus, it’s free from wheat, corn, soy, and poultry by-products for easy digestion.

Indulge your furry friend with this tasty, wholesome option.

Best For: Dogs of all ages and breeds looking for a nutritious and tasty dog food.

  • High-quality protein from real, deboned salmon as the first ingredient
  • Antioxidant-rich veggies and fiber-rich grains for overall wellbeing
  • DHA for brain and vision development
  • Some dogs may experience diarrhea or skin issues
  • May not be suitable for dogs with sensitive stomachs
  • May not be suitable for dogs with allergies to chicken or fish

2. Nom Nom Dog GI Probiotics

Nom Nom Dog GI-Targeted ProbioticView On Amazon
You can trust Nom Nom Dog GI Probiotics to care for your picky pup’s digestive health.

With 20 billion CFUs and 5 probiotic strains per serving, this high-quality supplement promotes healthy gut bacteria.

The inclusion of yeast (Saccharomyces boulardii) and chicory root inulin aids stool quality and digestion.

Made in the USA, it’s safe for puppies over 8 weeks and dogs of all breeds.

Best For: Dogs of all breeds, over 8 weeks old, with digestive issues.

  • High concentration of 20 billion CFUs per serving
  • Contains 5 probiotic strains and yeast (Saccharomyces boulardii)
  • Made in the USA with high-quality ingredients
  • Requires refrigeration for optimal preservation
  • May not be suitable for dogs with severe digestive problems
  • Expensive compared to other probiotic supplements

3. Open Farm Freeze Dried Raw Dog Food

Open Farm Freeze Dried RawView On Amazon
You crave the wild, nutrient-dense diet your pup was born to eat.

Open Farm’s Freeze Dried Raw Dog Food scratches that itch with humanely raised turkeys—no antibiotics or growth hormones.

These compact, soft-ish nuggets pack a protein punch (37% minimum!) while staying travel-friendly.

Mix them into meals, rehydrate for a meaty treat, or use as training rewards.

Your furry carnivore will go nuts for nature’s best.

Best For: Dogs craving a wild, nutrient-dense diet

  • High protein count (37% min)
  • Made with humanely raised turkeys
  • Compact and travel-friendly
  • Expensive
  • Small quantity
  • Excessive amount of bones found in recent batches

4. Human Grade Wet Dog Food

JustFoodForDogs Pantry Fresh Wet DogView On Amazon
You want to treat your furry pal to the best. Human Grade Wet Dog Food is a game-changer for picky eaters.

It’s made from fresh, whole foods cooked gently to maximize nutrient absorption – 40% more digestible than kibble!

Plus, these shelf-stable wet food pouches can be a complete meal or a flavor-packed topper.

Your pup’s tail will wag for the deliciousness.

Best For: Active adult dogs seeking a nutritious and highly digestible food option.

  • 100% human-grade ingredients with fresh whole foods
  • Gently cooked for optimal nutrient absorption
  • 40% more digestible than kibble
  • May be more expensive than traditional kibble
  • Requires refrigeration after opening
  • Transition to a whole food diet should be gradual over 5-10 days

5. Honest Kitchen Human Grade Dog Food

The Honest Kitchen Human GradeView On Amazon
You deserve to treat your picky pup to The Honest Kitchen’s human-grade, dehydrated dog food. Their recipes, like Whole Grain Chicken, use free-range chicken and non-GMO produce – making mealtime a healthy indulgence. Just add warm water to rehydrate and serve – it’s that easy! With no by-products or preservatives, you can feel good about nourishing your four-legged family member.

Best For: Dogs with sensitive stomachs or allergies.

  • Human-grade ingredients
  • No by-products or preservatives
  • Easy to prepare
  • Dehydrated food requires rehydration
  • May be more expensive than other dog food options
  • Not as widely available as other dog food brands

6. Go Solutions Grain Free Dog Food

GO! SOLUTIONS Carnivore Grain FreeView On Amazon
If your pup turns their nose up at grains, Go Solutions Grain Free Dog Food could be the answer.

This drool-worthy formula is packed with real meat, fruits, and veggies for a protein-packed punch your finicky friend will go wild for.

With zero grains, gluten, or fillers, it’s easy on sensitive tummies too.

And the mouthwatering aromas? Let’s just say even the pickiest pups do a happy dance when this dish is served.

Best For: Dogs with grain sensitivities or finicky eaters

  • Protein-rich with 85% of protein coming from premium-quality meat and fish
  • Grain-free, gluten-free, and filler-free
  • Made with real meat, fruits, and vegetables
  • May be more expensive than other dog foods
  • Not suitable for dogs with meat allergies
  • Limited ingredient recipes may not be suitable for all dogs

7. Leaping Waters Dry Dog Food

Solid Gold Leaping Waters -View On Amazon
You’ll love Leaping Waters’ natural dry salmon and veggie recipe for your picky pooch.

It’s packed with 90 million live probiotics per pound to support digestion and immunity.

Plus, 20 superfoods provide a nutrient-rich, cleansing boost.

The cold-water salmon offers an enticing aroma and flavor that even finicky eaters crave.

Best of all, it’s made in the USA without artificial dyes, BHA, BHT, or carrageenan.

Best For: Finicky dogs who need digestive and immune support.

  • Contains 90 million live probiotics per pound for digestion and immunity
  • Made with 20 superfoods for a nutrient-rich boost
  • Cold-water salmon flavor that even picky eaters crave
  • Packaging may vary
  • Not warranted for products sold through unauthorized resellers
  • Single source protein recipe (may not be suitable for all dogs)

8. Nulo Freestyle Grain Free Dog Food

Nulo Freestyle All Breed DogView On Amazon
You’ll love Nulo Freestyle Grain Free for your picky pup – it boasts high-quality proteins like trout, turkey, or lamb as the #1 ingredient. With gut-friendly probiotics, this nutrient-dense kibble supports digestive and immune health. Plus, it’s grain-free, so no pesky allergens. Omega fatty acids promote a shiny coat while antioxidants boost overall vitality. This low-carb formula satisfies even the pickiest eaters. Give your furry friend the nutritious, delicious fuel they crave!

Best For: Picky eaters looking for a high-quality, grain-free dog food.

  • High-quality protein sources as the #1 ingredient
  • Gut-friendly probiotics for digestive and immune health
  • Omega fatty acids for a shiny coat and antioxidants for overall vitality
  • May be expensive compared to other dog foods
  • Some dogs may be allergic to canola oil
  • Low-carb formula may not be suitable for all dogs

9. IAMS Minichunks Dry Dog Food

IAMS Proactive Health Minichunks AdultView On Amazon
You’ll be pleased with IAMS Minichunks Dry Dog Food if your picky pooch craves smaller kibble.

It’s made with real chicken as the first ingredient and contains antioxidants for immune health.

The customized blend of fiber and prebiotics supports healthy digestion—a boon for finicky eaters.

Plus, its smaller size makes it ideal for toy and small breeds who may struggle with larger bites.

Best For: Picky eaters, toy, and small breeds who struggle with larger bites.

  • Smaller kibble size for easy chewing
  • Supports healthy digestion with fiber and prebiotics
  • Enriched with antioxidants for immune health
  • Not specified
  • Not specified
  • Not specified

10. Wellness Natural Turkey Chicken Wet Dog Food

Wellness Natural Pet Food COREView On Amazon
You’ll love the smooth, irresistible pâté texture of Wellness Natural Turkey & Chicken Wet Dog Food. It’s grain-free and packed with premium proteins like real turkey and chicken, delivering complete nutrition. With no corn, wheat, soy, or artificial additives, this all-natural recipe supports your pup’s overall health and well-being. Made in the USA, it satisfies even the pickiest pooch’s cravings.

Best For: Adult dogs who thrive on a natural diet mainly comprised of meat.

  • Grain-free with real turkey and chicken for complete nutrition
  • Smooth pâté texture for irresistible taste
  • Made with premium all-natural ingredients
  • Can be more expensive than other dog foods
  • May not be suitable for dogs with certain allergies or sensitivities
  • Not as widely available as some other dog foods

Why Dogs Become Picky Eaters

Why Dogs Become Picky Eaters
You may be questioning why your beloved companion has become a discerning diner.

Believe it or not, there are several reasons behind this behavior.

Initially, underlying health concerns can impact a dog’s appetite and taste preferences.

Subsequently, an aversion to their current food, whether it’s the flavor, texture, or lack of variety, can lead to boredom and picky eating habits.

Indulging your pup with excessive treats can also make them hold out for those delectable morsels instead of their regular meals.

Some dogs simply have discerning tastes regarding the fat-to-protein ratio or overall tastiness of their food.

Understanding these factors is key to enticing even the most finicky of eaters.

Enticing Aromas and Flavors

Enticing Aromas and Flavors
You’ve covered why dogs become picky eaters, so let’s explore enticing aromas and flavors that can tempt even the most finicky pup. Dogs have an incredible sense of smell and taste, with a staggering:

  1. Up to 300 million olfactory receptors (compared to 6 million in humans)
  2. Around 1,700 active genes for smell detection
  3. Roughly 125 million smell-sensitive cells
  4. Taste buds spanning the roof, sides, and back of their tongues

Discover dog foods rich in savory meat proteins, umami flavors, and appetite-stimulating fats. High-quality, cooked proteins like chicken, beef, or salmon emit irresistible aromas that activate a dog’s olfactory system, triggering hunger cues. Don’t underestimate the power of enticing smells and flavors to awaken your picky pup’s appetite!

Switching Food Types and Textures

Switching Food Types and Textures
Regarding finicky eaters, diversifying food types and textures can work wonders.

Try alternating between wet and dry foods.

Introduce fresh or frozen options.

Consider raw or dehydrated recipes for an added boost of flavor and texture that might pique your pup’s interest.

Keep in mind that abrupt dietary changes can lead to digestive upset.

Make any changes gradually.

Consult your veterinarian if your dog’s pickiness persists or is accompanied by other concerning symptoms.

Wet Vs Dry Foods

You’ve tackled enticing flavors, now consider switching between wet and dry foods. Wet foods have a shorter shelf life but are more palatable, while dry kibble lasts longer but may need toppers. Here’s a handy comparison:

Feature Wet Food Dry Food
Texture Moist, softer Crunchy, hard
Aroma Stronger, more appealing Milder scent
Portion Size Smaller servings Larger portions
Cost Generally higher Often cheaper
Storage Refrigerated after opening Room temperature

Rotate between types to keep meals exciting for your picky pup.

Fresh and Frozen Foods

Picky eaters often devour fresh, human-grade dog meals – they’re irresistible! Freeze-dried and air-dried treats entice with concentrated flavors. Raw goat milk adds a nutritional kick. Fresh cooked meals with limited, whole food ingredients are the ultimate enticement for finicky pups craving variety and quality on par with human food.

Raw and Dehydrated Foods

You can also tempt picky pooches with raw or dehydrated dog foods**. These human-grade, grain-free options deliver a big flavor punch from ingredients like freeze-dried or air-dried meats and veggies. Plus, the unique textures and irresistible aromas may spark your furbaby’s appetite when kibble falls flat. With raw diets and dehydrated foods, you’re serving up nature’s original dog cuisine.

Healthy Food Toppers and Mixers

Healthy Food Toppers and Mixers
If your dog is a picky eater, try adding healthy food toppers and mixers to make their meals more enticing. Bone broth, chicken broth, Greek yogurt, cottage cheese, fresh fruits and vegetables, boiled chicken, and scrambled eggs can add flavor, moisture, and nutrients to your dog’s regular food, encouraging them to eat willingly.

Bone Broth and Chicken Broth

Kick things up a notch with bone broth or chicken broth! These flavorful liquids deliver:

  • Hydration to prevent dry kibble bloat
  • Protein for stamina and muscle tone
  • Electrolytes for ideal body functions

Plus, the irresistible aromas entice even the fussiest eaters. Simply pour over kibble or mix into wet food for a tasty, nutritious boost!

Greek Yogurt and Cottage Cheese

If your pup’s still turning up their nose, why not try Greek yogurt or cottage cheese? Both are packed with probiotics to support digestion and calcium for strong bones. Greek yogurt also offers protein and healthy fats.

Topper Benefits
Greek Yogurt Probiotics, protein, calcium, omega-3s
Cottage Cheese Calcium, protein, zinc amino acid chelate

These dairy delights add tantalizing texture and flavor to tempt even the pickiest pup.

Fresh Fruits and Vegetables

You can also add fresh, frozen, or lightly steamed produce to entice your pup’s taste buds. Consider:

  • Raw or dehydrated apple slices
  • Mashed banana or pumpkin puree
  • Finely chopped spinach, carrots, or green beans

Fresh fruits and veggies not only boost flavor but also provide essential vitamins and minerals for your furry friend’s overall health.

Boiled Chicken and Scrambled Eggs

You can’t go wrong by topping your pup’s food with boiled chicken or scrambled eggs! These protein-packed toppers are lip-smackingly delicious and biologically appropriate for dogs. Plus, they’re rich in essential nutrients like chelated minerals to meet a picky eater’s needs. A tasty, homemade complement to any dog’s meal!

Boiled Chicken Scrambled Eggs
Lean protein High-quality protein
Low-fat option Rich in vitamins
Palatability boost Egg-cellent flavor
Great for training Irresistible aroma

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What food is good for picky dogs?

For picky dogs, try mixing wet food with dry kibble or adding low-sodium broth toppers. Fresh foods like boiled chicken or scrambled eggs can entice finicky eaters too. It may take some trial and error, but being patient and rotating protein sources often works.

What is the best dog food for a dog that won’t eat?

Wouldn’t it be ironic if your dog refused the "best food for picky eaters"? Introduce novel protein sources, like bison or duck, slowly. Check for allergies. Warm and add tasty low-sodium broth. With patience and persistence, even the pickiest pooch will eat.

What food is irresistible to dogs?

You can tempt even the pickiest pup with tasty, high-quality food. Opt for moist, flavorful recipes bursting with enticing aromas – think fresh meat or irresistible fish. Add hydrating bone broth or a sprinkling of healthy treats to pique their interest. With patience and creativity, they’ll happily lick their bowls clean.

What do you feed a fussy dog?

Let’s face it, a fussy pup can make mealtimes frustrating. Try mixing canned or freshly cooked meat and veggies with their kibble – the irresistible aroma lures even the pickiest eaters. With patience and creativity, you’ll have that tail wagging again in no time!

How do I transition my dog to a new food?

Change your pup gradually, mixing some new food into their current diet over 5-7 days. Going slow prevents tummy troubles. Offer tasty toppers like warm broth to make the new grub extra enticing.

Can I make homemade dog food for picky eaters?

Yes, you can make homemade dog food for picky eaters. It allows you to control ingredients and provide variety. However, consult your vet to guarantee the diet meets your dog’s nutritional needs and for recipe guidance.

How much should I feed my picky dog daily?

You should feed your picky dog the recommended daily portion for its ideal weight, splitting it into two meals. If your dog leaves food, remove it after 20 minutes and try again at the next meal. Consistency and patience are key with finicky eaters.

Are there supplements to increase my dogs appetite?

Did you know picky eating behaviors affect 33% of dogs? Consult your vet about safe appetite stimulants like high-protein treats or nutri-supplemented broths. They’ll make sure any supplements complement your dog’s diet properly.

What are signs my dogs pickiness is health-related?

Signs your pup’s pickiness is health-related include sudden changes in appetite, lethargy, vomiting, or diarrhea. If your dog refuses meals for more than a day, it’s best to consult your vet to rule out underlying medical issues.


Breaking the cycle of a picky eater requires patience and persistence, but the best dog food for picky eaters can make all the difference.

From enticing aromas to novel textures, there’s a tasty solution to tempt even the most discerning pooch.

With a little creativity and the right nutritional approach, you can transform mealtime into a tail-wagging affair that satisfies both taste buds and dietary needs.

Avatar for Mutasim Sweileh

Mutasim Sweileh

Mutasim is the founder and editor-in-chief with a team of qualified veterinarians, their goal? Simple. Break the jargon and help you make the right decisions for your furry four-legged friends.